One Guy's Investments

The story of Travis Johnson's investment portfolio, with analysis and thoughts on the stocks and funds I've considered, bought and sold. I don't claim to have brilliant picks that will make you money, and I'm not an investment advisor, registered or otherwise, so don't follow my moves unless you're happy to lose money without suing someone. I'm just one guy. My articles get republished in several places, but always appear here first -- subscribe now(totally free via RSS) to see them before they're on Yahoo Finance.

Tuesday, March 14, 2006 -- Subscribe free

World's Worst Market Timer (OSTK)

Well, I'm still comfortable with my decision to sell Overstock.com (OSTK -- click to register for free RT streaming quote) in the abstract, but I'm definitely beating myself up over the timing.

I had plenty of patience to watch it ride down and down and down as I pondered whether or not I thought the company could recover and the CEO could refocus on the business. After all that pondering, it finally became apparent to me that the company wasn't one that I wanted to continue owning and I sold my shares last week.

Immediately after I sold, the stock launched one of the more remarkable two-day rallies I've yet seen from a company that hasn't released any earnings or news of any sort. I'm not sure what caused it -- Overstock thumbed their noses at Gradient again last week, but that was before I sold. And TheStreet.com posted an article about how undervalued OSTK is, but it doesn't make sense that this one article would change everyone's minds just by comparing OSTK's valuation to Amazon's. There wasn't any data in that article that wasn't already available to everyone.

So I definitely don't understand it. If I had been a couple days more patient in making my sell decision I would have gotten a price about 25% better than the one I sold at on Friday. Arg.

Long term, I still think Overstock is a great concept that's not being well executed, and a solid business that has some huge competitors who I expect will bear down further on OSTK as it continues to grow. I wish the Byrne's and their company well in my absence, and I'm happy to be out of the company, but boy does my timing ever stink.

Labels: ,

Keep up with One Guy's Investments, Free Subscription
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Comments:
I'm also wondering what made OSTk move without apparent reason

Two days ago I was close to do a bear spread on it, luckily I chickened out.

Too bad for you, but all in all I think you should be happy to be out of that stock

Good picking on GOL and MKL, even though I'm skeptical on the latter (at least skeptical that it could pull a BRKB, but not that it should go up)
 
i am pretty sure Alsin's realmoney article made it pop....look at the time when it was published.
 
Thanks for the comments.

Thiago, I agree, it looks like that Realmoney/Street.com article was the impetus for OSTK booming ... but that's awfully frightening if true, since all he did was call to our attention a comparison between Amazon, which I considered wildly overvalued and think is better compared to Wal Mart or Target at this point, and Overstock. No new news there, which may be why OSTK is falling back today.

Mathieu, I agree that MKL is unlikely to make it to the heights occupied by Berkshire -- but it seems a solid bet and it's following a similar strategy and keeping a ver long term focus, which I like. The management team at Markel receives bonuses based on the five-year growth in book value, which I find reassuring.

Thanks to both of you for reading.
 
Post a Comment



<< Home

Google
Stock Gumshoe's Latest Sponsored Links:
Check Stock Prices
 Symbol
A-Z market search               
Go
finance research tool powered by ADVFN

Advertise on blogs Blogarama - The Blogs
Bloggernity blog search directory
Blog Catalog
Find Blogs in the Blog Directory

PhatInvestor
Listed on BlogShares
Technorati Blog Finder
Top-Blogs Directory
Directory of Investing Blogs
Business Blog Top Sites
Today

Powered by Blogger

More blogs about investments.