One Guy's Investments

The story of Travis Johnson's investment portfolio, with analysis and thoughts on the stocks and funds I've considered, bought and sold. I don't claim to have brilliant picks that will make you money, and I'm not an investment advisor, registered or otherwise, so don't follow my moves unless you're happy to lose money without suing someone. I'm just one guy. My articles get republished in several places, but always appear here first -- subscribe now(totally free via RSS) to see them before they're on Yahoo Finance.

Thursday, July 06, 2006 -- Subscribe free

Expanding with Other Peoples' Money (WFR)

I continue to be very encouraged by the progress MEMC Electronic Materials (WFR) is making in diversifying their revenue streams and expanding their production capacity.

WFR is a silicon wafer manufacturer, and supplies both the semiconductor and solar cell industries. In the past, the semiconductor industry has been the dominant consumer of polysilicon and of silicon wafers, but the surging growth of solar power due to high oil prices and higher government subsidies has completely changed the demand picture for MEMC's products over the past two years.

WFR announced earlier this year that they planned to double their polysilicon production and, as a result, doubling their revenue by the end of the decade.

Polysilicon shortages have been a critical problem for both wafer makers and solar power companies recently, as evidenced by the beating Evergreen Solar (ESLR) took when WFR announced that they were reneging on their agreement to supply ESLR. But WFR, unlike most in the industry, makes their own polysilicon and has a vertically integrated supply chain that gives them significant cost advantages over their competitors who have to buy this raw material on the overheated spot market.

But more recently, MEMC has taken a few steps to greatly reduce the cost and risk of this massive capacity expansion and give them some additional exposure to the solar power market.
Back in April, WFR made a deal with Motech, a solar cell manufacturer, that essentially gave them a big cash infusion and a piece of the action (a warrant for 5% of Motech shares). I wrote about that at the time, and I still think it was a smart deal.

But it fell apart. The parties announced today that the deal wasn't going to work for their needs and allowed the letter of intent to dissolve.

And good news sprung from the ashes -- MEMC has now signed a similar letter of intent with another solar company, Suntech Power (STP), that is seeing huge growth and is working hard to ensure adequate wafer supply to help them keep up with demand.

As a low-cost solar power producer in China, a market that has made a huge commitment to expanding solar power use, Suntech is probably a stronger upside bet for future growth of the solar industry, and I think the potential for WFR to acquire 5% of STP as a part of this deal is very promising -- more promising than a position in Motech would be.

We'll see if it works out this time -- the fact that they're essentially replacing one deal with another shouldn't have a huge impact on the stock (the shares jumped up huge in pre-market, but settled down quickly when realization set in that they weren't going forward with both deals). I do, however, think STP is a marginally stronger partner than Motech and I'll be happy to see this deal succeed if they can work out the details -- we should know by the end of August whether the Letter of Intent will generate a binding deal.

MEMC Electronic Materials has come a long way since it's lowest days about two years ago -- it's no longer the 200% winner for me that it was at the peak in May, but I have every confidence that this will remain a smart investment thanks to their continued solid growth, smart financing as evidenced by these two prospective deals, and diversity of income streams as the solar and semiconductor industries both continue to expand in volume.

Labels:

Keep up with One Guy's Investments, Free Subscription
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Comments:
Way to go with WFR. You write a positive note and it plunges. I'll keep that in mind when evaluating your other writings. :)

Any thoughts on the Monday July 10 $2.00 plunge in WFR? No apparent news, average volume...
 
Definitely not the first time that has happened -- though usually they only go down when I buy more :)

I think you said it -- no news, average volume, the semiconductors and solar power guys are both being beat up pretty badly today, especially the smaller names, and WFR is pretty heavily influenced by the semis. It's been a volatile stock for the past year or so, I've seen a lot of moves like this and am not worried. Right now, the aggressive growers seem to be catching ebola whenever the market catches a cold, but I don't imagine that will last forever.
 
A couple of months later, is it worth re-visiting WFR?

The stock took a TERRIBLE dive into the twenties, then staged a MIRACULOUS recovery (along with the QQQQs?) back into the high thirties.

Technicians following the stock seem confused now, as some believe the recovery may be about to stall at resistance.

Analysts and investors also appear confused, particularly on the impact of new polysilicon capacity coming online in 2007/2008 (in, of all places, China, land of STP).

I've traded around a core position in the stock, even loading up on calls in the twenties (where the valuation was just stupidly low), after dumping puts too soon in the thirties (right before the plunge, ouch), and finally I wrote covered calls at 35 (which was a powerful pin for August), pre-cursor to unloading half my position (which was the largest in my portfolio). Overall I've made much more money than I've lost, as the crazy roller-coaster ride has allowed for some great trading. But the risks are getting very hard to fathom.

Any views on what might lie ahead with fundamentals? Your position has been that continued demand for polySi will be beneficial for WFR, any second thoughts?
 
Thanks for the comment -- sounds like at least one person's trying to keep me honest on MEMC.

It's true that the supply of polysilicon is going to be a significant driver of WFR's value -- but I expect demand to grow as well. This certainly has all the indications of being a possible tipping point for the industry, as a huge new customer grows from the ashes (solar power) and spurs investments in new capacity that might throw the market out of wack.

I think management was smart to make a long term deal with STP, including warrants for some additional upside, and I'd like to see them lock in some more long term sales this way at reasonable prices to help smooth out the bumps of additional supply sources coming online.

I do expect both semiconductor volume and solar cell volume to increase over time at a fairly significant rate, though I can't guarantee that the demand growth will outpace supply. I don't think MEMC is overvalued at the current price, but I also don't think it's a screaming bargain as it was in the teens and 20s.

This has happened with several other businesses I've owned in the past -- the fear of a future glut has depressed stock prices even when demand was high and performance excellent, and in some cases ... as with oil tankers, for a recent example ... the demand has continued to grow and the supply has come on so incrementally that the impact was much more muted, or delayed, than expected.

I expect to do some more research on this in the coming weeks, so I'll post any new thougths I have. Thanks for reading.
 
Post a Comment



<< Home

Google
Stock Gumshoe's Latest Sponsored Links:
Check Stock Prices
 Symbol
A-Z market search               
Go
finance research tool powered by ADVFN

Advertise on blogs Blogarama - The Blogs
Bloggernity blog search directory
Blog Catalog
Find Blogs in the Blog Directory

PhatInvestor
Listed on BlogShares
Technorati Blog Finder
Top-Blogs Directory
Directory of Investing Blogs
Business Blog Top Sites
Today

Powered by Blogger

More blogs about investments.