Not signed in (Sign In)

Categories

Vanilla 1.1.2 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

Welcome Guest!
Want to take part in these discussions? If you have an account, sign in now.
If you don't have an account, apply for one now.
  1.  Report Post# 1
    Here's a simple idea for you to research. If you find it useful, "cheers". If not, just disregard it.

    Pull up a P&F chart for VXO. Note the bearish resistance line. Note further the last 3 times an X reaches or exceeds the line. That would be March 6th, April 1st and April 28th.

    Now pull up a chart for almost any S&P stock. Plug in those dates on the chart and ask yourself whether those would have been good days to buy the stock.

    Aside from the obvious point, it is time to be very patient about when you open new positions and add to existing ones. When you do, it might be wise to take a peek at VXO to see where it is in relation to its BRL.

    This isn't foolproof and it's just another tool to use........but if and when VXO hits the 36-37 area....
    • CommentAuthorSMcGuire45
    • CommentTimeMay 27th 2009
     Report Post# 2
    SpreadTrader,

    What's the difference between the VXO and the VIX?

    Thanks as always!

    SM
  2.  Report Post# 3
    Both VIX and VXO are measures of option volatility on the S&P 500 (VIX) and the S&P 100 (VXO).

    This is VIX and how it is calculated:

    The CBOE SPX Volatility Index is calculated and disseminated in real-time by the CBOE. It is a weighted blend of prices for a range of options on the S&P 500 index. The formula uses a kernel-smoothed estimator that takes as inputs the current market prices for all out-of-the-money calls and puts for the front month and second month expirations. The goal is to estimate the implied volatility of a synthetic, at-the-money option on the S&P 500 index, with 30 days to expiration.

    This is VXO:

    The CBOE OEX Volatility Index reflects a market consensus estimate of future volatility, based on "at the money" quotes of OEX Index Options.

    This is OEX and its options:

    The Standard & Poor's 100 Index (OEX) is a capitalization-weighted index of 100 blue chip, large cap stocks from the U.S equities marketplace from diverse industry sector groups. It is a broad market index; together these 100 stocks represent over 50% of the market capitalization of the S&P 500® Index. The impact of a price change in any component stock on the level of the overall index is proportional to the issue’s total market value. Options on the S&P 100 are used primarily by hedgers and speculators in conjunction with bullish or bearish opinions on large-cap U.S. stocks.

    For me, the actual formulas that comprise how the values are arrived at are meaningless. I simply don't do math....well, I can do some. But I really just want to see the relative relationships on a chart as the values change.

    This is a website that I don't frequent, but it looks like it may have in depth information on interpreting VIX and VXO:

    http://vixandmore.blogspot.com/2008/08/overview-of-us-volatility-indices.html

    I think they charge a fee if you want to hang out there. Hope this helps.

    .....oh, I chose VXO as my "indicator" because of how its chart looks in hindsight in relation to price action in the S&P for this short term rally. There will likely come a time when this will no longer work; and it may be that VIX will have better correlation to market tops and bottoms. It just seemed to me that VXO is a better "indicator" for the moment.
    Thankful People: Patches, SMcGuire45
  3.  Report Post# 4
    Perhaps I should add, not only are VXO and VIX useful as indicators for timing market reversals. They literally measure a key pricing component for options. As I've said in other posts, there are three components to how options are valued: 1) price of the underlying security; 2) time value, or life of the option; and 3) implied volatility. Number 3 is measured by VIX and VXO (at least for the indices that they represent). Option traders need to understand the impact of implied volatility on option pricing.
    Thankful People: SMcGuire45
    • CommentAuthorSMcGuire45
    • CommentTimeMay 29th 2009
     Report Post# 5
    ST,

    Thanks for the info about the VIX and VXO. I've been just trying to soak everything in like a sponge for the last couple of years, but I still have a long way too go! I watch the VIX, but have never really followed the VXO. Just another symbol to add to my daily list...

    Thanks!

    SM
    Thankful People: spreadtrader
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeMay 30th 2009
     Report Post# 6
    ST, this is a VERY interesting find. I compared a couple of S&P stocks to your hypothesis and it was true to form. But I am a little confused on this one. If volatility goes down, why would stocks surge upwards? I would think more volatility would move stocks.

    I don't use P&F charts much, but I see their benefit in a case like this and would really like to explore it further. Where do you go for your P&F charts? The sites I use for analysis have lousy ones.
  4.  Report Post# 7
    I use http://dorseywright.com/

    A subscription is $35 a month and it's one of the best investments in trading education I've ever made. The site has encyclopedic information besides charting services, both foreign and domestic; and once you get familiar with comparing stocks on a relative strength basis, you'll find it invaluable. Ask F5, he's the P&F expert.

    To answer your question, to me, the real meaning of volatility (in the stock market anyway) is "fear". In fact, you've probably heard of the VIX described as the "fear index". The theory is (and it's pretty solid) that as the market falls, fear rises. As fear rises, VIX and VXO rise. As investors become complacent or ambivalent to fear, volatility falls. Generally, that's how it works. Many contrarians use VIX and VXO as market indicators.

    What hasn't been discussed much is the impact of "greed" (or a feeding frenzy at market tops) on VXO and VIX. I haven't studied it, but I imagine that VIX and VXO are affected similarly. It's just that when a "feeding frenzy" happens, it is usually at the end of an extended period of complacency (low volatility), so it doesn't register on the chart quite like "fear" does. Look at historic charts of the S&P and compare the extremes in price to the corresponding chart readings for VIX (as VIX has been around longer).
    Thankful People: Patches, SMcGuire45
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeMay 30th 2009
     Report Post# 8
    Perfect explanation ST. I was thinking too literally on VXO and VIX. I'll have to go back and check the charts for 2008 as well. If this is an accurate measure of fear, this could be a huge indicator. I really appreciate the tip!

    I will also look into dorseywright.com. Price isn't bad for all the potential benefits.
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeMay 31st 2009
     Report Post# 9
    ST, Do you see anything in the VXO to indicate a reversal is here? Your 36-37 range looks to have moved down to 33-34. Would the O's need to move to 26 before you see a reversal pattern setting up?
    • CommentAuthorSMcGuire45
    • CommentTimeMay 31st 2009
     Report Post# 10
    I also subscribe to DorseyWright and have found the site excellent and invaluable so far!
    • CommentAuthordharouff
    • CommentTimeMay 31st 2009
     Report Post# 11
    I've tried a couple of sites to do compare, most don't do VIX or VXO. What site do you use?
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeMay 31st 2009 edited
     Report Post# 12
    I'm using http://www.stockcharts.com. Here's the direct link: http://stockcharts.com/def/servlet/SC.pnf?c=$VXO,P
    You have to type in VXO, not ^VXO.

    Assuming you were taking to me. :)
    • CommentAuthoreds
    • CommentTimeMay 31st 2009
     Report Post# 13
    Another way to think about volatility is to think about how it stretches out the probability distribution of returns. Sure there is the probability of greater upside, but there is also the probability of greater downside. The expected return would be a weighted average of all the returns and it is likely this return declines when VIX rises because of a lack of symetry and downside returns likely carry higher weights during that period.
    • CommentAuthordharouff
    • CommentTimeMay 31st 2009
     Report Post# 14
    It was an open question. I was trying to overlay the symbols. Yahoo and Google will sort of. I do have a set of singles that I run daily with Firefox and Stockcharts using firefox's 'open all in tabs' function.
  5.  Report Post# 15
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeJun 7th 2009
     Report Post# 16
    Spread, you may be on to something here with the VXO. All market indicators are screaming for a pullback/reversal, yet the Dow, S&P and NASDAQ are climbing along with the rest of the market. Not coincidentally, the VXO and VIX are still trending down. I am watching this one very carefully to see if a move in the VXO above 33 will trigger a market sell-off. If so, I think I may owe you a case of your Williamette Wine. :)
    Thankful People: spreadtrader
  6.  Report Post# 17
    I'll be sure to remind you..........lol.
    Thankful People: Patches
    • CommentAuthorDarrell
    • CommentTimeJun 7th 2009
     Report Post# 18
    We're getting so many reports of banks using toxic assets in the wring way but allowed by regulators to maybe pump the recovery, so how do we know which charts, etc. to believe ?? I know foreclosures are on the edge of exploding again from local reports in states I have friends and family in and it doesn't seem to be affecting the market. Government printing more money, forgiving loans, helping in takeovers, buyouts, etc., somrthing just ain't right or I'm to much a cynic.
    Thankful People: Patches
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeJun 7th 2009
     Report Post# 19
    Darrell, you may be right. Stansberry's Short guru, Jeff Clark wrote on Friday that he and a bunch of his friends who trade for a living think there is some monkey business going on in the pits. They are all massively short in the market and so far losing their shirt. With so much big money shorting stocks, the market should be moving down. But so far the Bulls are winning. We know the government has done everything it can to prop the market up with the treasury and the media. Maybe they are also working behind the curtain?
  7.  Report Post# 20
    Hi Darrell,

    Your comments/question tell me that this rally likely isn't over. The reason is that there are far too many people like you who are worried that the market will reverse here. At the same time, they are worried that they will miss the rally. That means that there is still a lot of cash on the sidelines itching to be invested. The bear market won't resume until people en masse decide whether: 1) they can overcome their fear of missing out and join in the rally (which should cause the market to go up); or 2) they can't stand to put more money into a dry hole (in which case, buying will cease, supply will take over and the market will indeed reverse and head south).

    Personally, based upon market price action in recent months, I think investors will opt for choice #1. If the market will correct and hold support, I think you're going to see a wave of liquidity hit the stock market. Remember, the market is a leading indicator. It will not do what you necessarily see happening around you as being logical. It not only already sees what you see, it has already factored it into prices.

    Here's a recent quote from George Soros (and I agree with it):

    "Asked if the recent climb in global stock markets was a bear market rally, he (Soros) said: 'It may have further to go because there is a lot of liquidity, a lot of investors are on the sidelines. If the market keeps on going up, more of them may decide to join in. You never know how far the rally goes. But I certainly don't think we are at the beginning of a big bull market worldwide.' "

    Here's the whole article:

    http://www.reuters.com/article/ousiv/idUSTRE5560M120090607?sp=true
    Thankful People: Independentguy, Patches
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeJun 7th 2009 edited
     Report Post# 21
    An excellent observation spread. I spoke with my Dad this morning. He pulled out all his 401K money back in mid 2008, and he's not planning on moving a penny back in until the government stops spending money. There's a lot of people like him out there, who have enough money in their account to ride this one out. But those could also very well be the people who may start jumping in. My dad did say he would only go back into the market by buying gold and silver stocks, and only do it with 25% of his money. He could be tempted if gold breaks above 1000.
  8.  Report Post# 22
    Yes, those folks are already reading about how the dollar has declined since March and will worry that it will have no buying power once the "ride" is over. They will plow their money into stocks (or bonds) and be left holding the bag when the bottom drops out because they still don't have a clue when to sell.
    • CommentAuthorDarrell
    • CommentTimeJun 7th 2009
     Report Post# 23
    spread. I'm looking to at least 6 mo. down the road and am confused by what I know and timing what I want to profit from without losing. Since I'm gambling so much in metals, bios, oil and gas..I am not in fear of missing out, just wanting to know when to move some money oneway or the other. Kell, it's about profits..right. Education is what I looking for more than anything, I guess and you have a good brain to pick.
  9.  Report Post# 24
    Thanks Darrell. But whether some (like you) are already in or not, everyone seems to be "confused" about what's next. Indecision isn't fear, but it also isn't confidence. I think this nice little rally we've had has to induce people to be confident before it will pull the rug out from under again. That's why I don't think the rally is over. Just a hunch from observing sentiment, especially on the "fear" charts (VIX and VXO). What will be critical is whether and to what extent VIX and/or VXO break through resistance on their charts. We're not there yet and not really even close with both charts still in O's.
    Thankful People: Darrell
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeJun 8th 2009 edited
     Report Post# 25
    Here's an interesting article on ETF inflows and outflows for May and 2009 overall:
    http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Investors-Pour-17-Billion-indexuniverse-15442042.html?.v=2

    It seems that for every 2.4 dollars put into bearish inverse ETFs, 2.5 dollars were put into regular ones, indicating people are jumping back in. I was wondering why the bears were losing. This would certainly support spread's idea that foolish investors are thinking they missed the rally. But it's extremely close. All it would take would be one piece of uncertain or bad news to push the bears ahead. I don't see that this week. In fact, banks are set to repay more TARP funds than previously estimated. People love to go on spending sprees based on better than estimated news. So the Bull is probably still in charge.

    Maybe gold breaking $1,000 could be the catalyst for a bear run.
    Thankful People: stockcrazy10, Darrell
  10.  Report Post# 26
    Weekly momentum turned positive for VIX on Friday and VXO, while still negative, looks like it is close behind (if it hits 29.60 it will turn). A correction for stocks may be at hand. For now, keep watching.
    Thankful People: stockcrazy10, dchanko, eds, Darrell
  11.  Report Post# 27
    SC10 pointed out to me that BOTH VXO and VIX have negative weekly momentum as of 5/22/09; and thus the weekly momentum for VIX is NOT positive.

    I see that the DW&A chart says that today. However, I swear that I read that the weekly momentum for VIX had turned to positive as of 6/5/09. The reason I believe that is because I doubled checked it thinking it was an anomaly.

    I suppose it is possible that I was looking at another chart. But this isn't the first time (I think) that they've changed up on me like that. I think it's a "computer" thing.

    .......anyhow, sorry for the mistake (whether it's mine or some computer).

    The implication of having negative weekly momentum for both VXO and VIX is intermediate term strength in the stock markets.
    Thankful People: Patches, Darrell
    • CommentAuthorPatches
    • CommentTimeJun 10th 2009
     Report Post# 28
    Thanks for the clarification Spread. Both VXO and VIX dropped 5% yesterday, which is a considerable move down for one day. I think it's going to take some big uncertainty in the market to stop this Bear market rally. Next month's Quarterly Financials maybe?
    • CommentAuthordharouff
    • CommentTimeJun 15th 2009
     Report Post# 29
    Interesting pattern http://stockcharts.com/charts/performance/perf.html?$VIX,dia,spy,qqqq
    right click the 200day bar and select 30 days then slide it over to current.
    Thankful People: SMcGuire45
  12.  Report Post# 30
    Watch VXO closely. It is one box from a triple top breakout and its bearish resistance line. It is also not far from reversing to a column of O's. Weekly momentum just turned positive, so it should linger here and perhaps even punch through to a new buy signal. But it may not. I'm selectively buying stock and call options here and stock more aggressively if it continues its move up.